Mediterranean Feta & Olive Pull-Apart Bread (Irresistibly Cheesy and Perfect for Sharing)

There are some recipes that quietly do their job, and then there are recipes that completely steal the show. This feta and olive pull-apart bread proudly belongs in the second category. It’s warm, indulgent, deeply flavorful, and impossible to ignore once it hits the table. Think crusty sourdough on the outside, soft and steamy on the inside, filled with melted cheese, briny olives, fresh herbs, garlic, and a fragrant spiced butter that soaks into every crack and crevice.

Save

This is not just bread. This is an experience.

If you’re looking for a crowd-pleasing appetizer that feels special without being complicated, this Mediterranean-inspired pull-apart loaf delivers every single time. It’s the kind of dish people hover around, tearing off piece after piece, asking who made it and how soon they can get the recipe.

Let’s Talk Seriously About This Bread

We need to pause for a moment and really appreciate what’s happening here.

A whole round of crusty sourdough is sliced into soft cubes but kept intact, creating little pockets just waiting to be filled. Those pockets are stuffed with a rich mixture of crumbled feta, gooey mozzarella, chopped olives, fresh dill, and garlic. Then everything is drenched in warm butter infused with aromatic spices and herbs before going into the oven.

As it bakes, the cheese melts, the butter sinks into the bread, and the crust turns golden and crisp. The aroma alone is enough to pull everyone into the kitchen before it’s even out of the oven.

This is comfort food with personality. Familiar, yet elevated. Rustic, yet impressive.

How This Recipe Became a Staple

This pull-apart bread was born from a simple idea: combining a love for feta cheese and olives with the comfort of warm, shareable bread. The first version came together almost by accident, thrown together for a holiday gathering with ingredients already on hand. It disappeared faster than anything else on the table.

Since then, it’s been made again and again, each time refined just a little more. Adjusting the cheese balance. Tweaking the herbs. Perfecting the butter mixture. The result is a recipe that feels both effortless and intentional, one that works for holidays, parties, and laid-back weekends alike.

Why You’ll Love This Pull-Apart Bread

This recipe checks all the right boxes:

• Perfect for sharing – Designed for groups, no slicing required
• Bold Mediterranean flavors – Salty olives, tangy feta, fresh herbs
• Minimal prep – Simple ingredients, quick assembly
• Visually impressive – Looks stunning straight from the oven
• Customizable – Easy to adapt with different herbs or olives

It’s the kind of appetizer that feels indulgent but approachable, ideal for both casual get-togethers and special occasions.

When to Serve It

One of the best things about this feta and olive pull-apart bread is its versatility. It fits seamlessly into so many moments:

• Game day or watch parties when you want something warm and satisfying
• Holiday gatherings where one dish needs to feed many people
• Family dinners as a starter that sets the tone
• Lazy weekends paired with a glass of crisp white wine
• Potlucks and parties where you want to arrive with something memorable

If you’re bringing it to someone else’s home, a quick reheat in the oven before serving brings it right back to life.

The Cheese and Olive Filling

The heart of this recipe is the filling. Crumbled feta brings a salty, tangy bite, while shredded mozzarella adds that irresistible stretch and melt. Olives provide depth and brininess, balancing the richness of the cheese. Fresh dill brightens everything, and garlic ties it all together with savory warmth.

The mixture is bold on its own, but once it’s tucked into the bread and baked, it becomes something even better. Every bite delivers contrast: crisp crust, soft interior, creamy cheese, and bursts of olive flavor.

Olive Tip

You can finely chop whole olives by hand or pulse them briefly in a food processor. The goal is small pieces that distribute evenly, with a few slices reserved for topping the bread at the end.

The Magic of Spiced Butter

What truly elevates this pull-apart bread is the butter. Melted slowly and infused with herbs and spices, it’s poured generously over the sliced loaf so it seeps into every layer.

This butter isn’t just fat for richness; it’s a flavor carrier. It coats the bread, enhances the herbs, and ensures the loaf bakes up moist and fragrant rather than dry.

If you don’t have a premade spice blend on hand, you can easily create a similar effect by combining dried herbs, sesame seeds, and aromatic seasonings. The result is warm, savory, and deeply comforting.

Preparing the Bread

The technique here is simple but important. The loaf is sliced in a crosshatch pattern, creating cubes without cutting all the way through. This keeps the bread intact while allowing space for the filling and butter to settle inside.

Once sliced, the bread is gently pulled apart, brushed with butter, and stuffed generously. Hands work best for this step, making sure the filling is evenly distributed throughout the loaf.

This method ensures that every pull delivers cheese, olives, and flavor—not just plain bread.

Baking, Serving, and Making It Unforgettable

Once your feta and olive pull-apart bread is assembled, the oven does the rest of the work. This is where everything transforms: the butter melts deeper into the loaf, the cheese becomes irresistibly gooey, and the crust develops a light crispness that contrasts perfectly with the soft interior.

As it bakes, the kitchen fills with the aroma of warm bread, garlic, herbs, and melted cheese. This is the moment when people start wandering in, asking what’s in the oven and when it will be ready. It’s nearly impossible to wait—but trust me, those few minutes are worth it.

Baking Tips for the Best Results

• Use a sturdy loaf: A round, crusty sourdough works best. Soft sandwich bread won’t hold the filling properly.
• Don’t cut all the way through: Keeping the base intact ensures the bread holds together while pulling apart easily.
• Distribute evenly: Take your time stuffing the filling into the loaf so every section gets cheese and olives.
• Serve warm: This bread truly shines when hot and fresh from the oven.

If you’re preparing it ahead of time, you can assemble everything, cover it loosely, and bake just before serving.

Finishing Touches

Once the bread comes out of the oven, a few simple toppings make all the difference. Extra sliced olives add visual appeal and reinforce the flavor, while fresh herbs bring brightness and color. A light sprinkle of dried herbs or spice blend on top enhances the aroma and gives the loaf a beautiful, rustic finish.

Place the whole loaf on a serving board or platter and let everyone pull pieces directly from the bread. No knives, no fuss—just warm, cheesy perfection meant to be shared.

Print